[thelist] a malicious site?
Barney Carroll
barney at textmatters.com
Tue Nov 28 04:43:58 CST 2006
Steven Streight wrote:
> Any site that must be viewed
> and interacted with via special plug-ins is a very stupid and poorly
> designed site.
It's important we remember that they're avoided not through spite but
simply because it's too much hassle. It's user patience, not designer
sympathy that should get us through the day.
Let's consider a few things: the prompt appears that way when using
Windows. It's standard practice for Windows to make everything look
dangerous because it always is. Windows Media files can do all sorts of
stuff without your express permission.
On my Mac I get no prompt, and when I come to the site it's a very
specifically geared animations depository. The internet can do a great
many things apart from clear legible documents in html and css, and even
if those are what I specialise in and enjoy most, it would be arrogant
and short-sighted of me to deny other purposes and technologies the
right to flourish.
Design is art within constraints, and this is an art-based site. A lot
of my favourite music and films are inaccessible, too. I don't hold it
against them because their content cannot be compromised - a thoroughly
accessible version of this site would be an exercise in futility. By its
nature it is impossible for it to degrade gracefully.
If we push rules and uniformity without being able to argue how the case
in point might benefit, we're at serious risk of being branded joyless
fascists.
Regards,
Barney
More information about the thelist
mailing list