Matt wrote: >http://news.com.com/2100-1023-962761.html In other news, another federal judge makes the opposite decision: http://www.sedbtac.org/ed/whats_new/articles.cfm?id=2520 So either: 1) In the US judicial system, precedent works in a daft fashion 2) The judge in the SWAir case got it wrong Cheers Martin